{
"label": "API experiment, not consumer app",
"run_id": "20261031T154343Z",
"engine": "gemini",
"model_requested": "gemini-2.5-flash",
"question_id": "q03",
"question": "Plausible vs Fathom vs Simple Analytics - which one should I choose for a small blog?",
"requested_at_utc": "2026-10-31T15:43:57Z",
"completed_at_utc": "2026-10-31T15:44:13Z",
"http_status": 200,
"latency_s": 16.19,
"attempts": 1,
"request_settings": {
"endpoint": "https://generativelanguage.googleapis.com/v1beta/models/gemini-2.5-flash:generateContent",
"tools": [
"google_search"
],
"max_output_tokens": 8000,
"system_instructions": "none",
"temperature": "API default",
"user_location": "not set"
},
"transport_error": null,
"response": {
"candidates": [
{
"content": {
"parts": [
{
"text": "For a small blog, choosing an analytics tool like Plausible, Fathom, or Simple Analytics means prioritizing privacy, simplicity, and ease of use over the complex, data-heavy features of tools like Google Analytics. All three are excellent privacy-focused alternatives that allow you to track website performance without relying on cookies or requiring intrusive consent banners.\n\nHere's a breakdown to help you decide:\n\n### Plausible Analytics\n\nPlausible is a lightweight, open-source web analytics tool built in Estonia and hosted on EU infrastructure. It offers a minimalist dashboard that is easy to understand, focusing on essential insights like pageviews, unique visitors, top pages, and referral sources.\n\n**Key Features for a Small Blog:**\n* **Privacy-Focused:** Plausible uses a sub-1KB script, collects no personal data, doesn't use cookies, and requires no consent banner in most jurisdictions, making it GDPR, CCPA, and PECR compliant.\n* **Open Source & Self-Hostable:** The full source code is available on GitHub, offering the option to self-host the entire stack for free if you prefer full data ownership.\n* **Simplicity:** Its dashboard is designed for quick readability, allowing users to grasp key metrics in under a minute.\n* **Event and Goal Tracking:** Plausible includes goal tracking and custom events even on its starter plans.\n* **EU Data Residency:** All hosted plans include EU data residency by default.\n\n**Pricing:**\n* Plausible's Starter plan costs $9 per month for one site, covering up to 10,000 monthly pageviews. Prices scale with traffic, and annual billing offers a discount.\n* A 30-day free trial is available, with full features and no credit card required.\n\n**Pros:**\n* Extremely simple and user-friendly interface.\n* Strong commitment to user privacy; no cookie banners needed.\n* Open-source nature provides transparency and the option for self-hosting.\n* Lightweight script ensures fast website performance.\n* Often reports more pageviews than Google Analytics due to bypassing ad blockers and consent rejections.\n* Includes goal and event tracking on lower tiers.\n\n**Cons:**\n* Lacks advanced product analytics features, complex funnels, or deep user journey analysis that larger businesses might need.\n* No built-in revenue metrics, requiring manual integration for e-commerce sites.\n* Pricing scales up for high-traffic sites, which can become more expensive.\n\n### Fathom Analytics\n\nFathom Analytics is known for its extreme simplicity, polished user experience, and strong focus on privacy. It's often recommended for agencies managing multiple client sites due to its generous site limits.\n\n**Key Features for a Small Blog:**\n* **Privacy-First:** Fathom is cookieless, doesn't collect personal data, and is GDPR compliant, eliminating the need for consent banners.\n* **Simplicity:** Offers a clean, single-page dashboard designed for quick and easy understanding of website performance.\n* **Unlimited Data Retention:** All plans include forever data retention.\n* **Custom Event Tracking:** Allows tracking of specific events like button clicks or form submissions.\n* **EU Data Isolation:** Provides automatic EU data routing for European visitors.\n\n**Pricing:**\n* Fathom's entry tier costs $15 per month for up to 100,000 pageviews across 50 sites.\n* A 7-day free trial is available, but it often requires credit card details upfront.\n\n**Pros:**\n* Exceptional ease of use and a very clean, intuitive dashboard.\n* Strong emphasis on privacy and GDPR compliance, no cookie banners.\n* Fast and lightweight script with minimal impact on website performance.\n* One plan covers a high number of sites (50 sites on the base plan), making it cost-effective for managing multiple blogs.\n* Responsive customer support.\n\n**Cons:**\n* Offers very basic metrics and limited advanced features like detailed funnels or deep user journey analysis.\n* No permanent free plan.\n* Trial sometimes requires credit card details.\n* Pricing can feel steep for very small websites with minimal traffic if only basic insights are needed.\n\n### Simple Analytics\n\nSimple Analytics prides itself on unmatched simplicity and a radical privacy-first approach. It's a cookie-free web analytics service from the Netherlands, focusing on providing essential data on a single-page dashboard.\n\n**Key Features for a Small Blog:**\n* **Extreme Simplicity:** Features a single-page dashboard that's scannable at a glance with zero learning curve.\n* **Privacy by Default:** Cookieless by design, collects no personal data, and bypasses ad blockers, ensuring accurate data without needing a consent banner.\n* **EU Hosted:** Data is hosted in the Netherlands and the EU.\n* **Retroactive Goal Tracking:** Allows you to define goals and see historical data from when Simple Analytics started collecting, not just from when the goal was set.\n* **AI Data Chat:** Features a built-in AI assistant for asking questions about your traffic.\n\n**Pricing:**\n* Simple Analytics offers a free \"hobby plan\" for up to 5 sites and 1 user, with a limitation of one month of data history and a required badge.\n* Paid plans offer a 14-day free trial (no credit card required).\n* Entry-tier pricing for paid plans is around $10-20/month billed annually for 100,000 pageviews, though custom events and goals might be gated to higher tiers.\n\n**Pros:**\n* Unmatched simplicity with a clean, intuitive, one-page dashboard.\n* Strongest privacy posture, collecting no personal data whatsoever.\n* Lightweight script that doesn't slow down your site and bypasses ad blockers for more accurate data.\n* Offers a free plan for hobby sites.\n* Retroactive goal tracking is a valuable feature.\n* Good customer support.\n\n**Cons:**\n* Deliberately limited in advanced features; no bounce rate, no cohort analysis, and limited detailed user journey paths.\n* Custom events and goals are often gated to higher-priced tiers.\n* Closed-source product.\n* Pricing scales with the entire portfolio's traffic, not per site.\n* Some users note occasional slow page loading times for the dashboard.\n\n### Recommendation for a Small Blog\n\nFor a small blog, the best choice among Plausible, Fathom, and Simple Analytics depends on your specific priorities:\n\n* **Choose Plausible if:**\n * You want a balance of simplicity and functionality, including basic event and goal tracking from the start.\n * You value open-source software and the option to self-host for ultimate control.\n * You are comfortable with a pricing model that scales with pageviews, even if you manage multiple sites (as long as your combined traffic stays within reasonable limits for the chosen plan).\n * You appreciate EU data residency by default.\n\n* **Choose Fathom if:**\n * You prioritize the absolute simplest, most polished, \"just the numbers\" dashboard without any distractions.\n * You might manage several small blogs or client sites under one account, as its base plan includes up to 50 sites.\n * You value unlimited data retention.\n * You don't need advanced analytics features beyond traffic, referrers, and basic events.\n\n* **Choose Simple Analytics if:**\n * You want the most privacy-focused tool that collects absolutely no personal data and offers unmatched simplicity in its dashboard.\n * You appreciate a free hobby plan, even with its limitations.\n * You like the idea of retroactive goal tracking and an AI chat assistant.\n * Your primary need is a clear, one-page overview of traffic and referrers without any complexity.\n\n**Conclusion:**\n\nAll three are excellent, privacy-respecting choices that are superior to Google Analytics for a small blog focused on simplicity and user privacy. For most small bloggers, **Plausible Analytics** often strikes the best balance between features (including basic goals/events on starter plans) and its open-source, privacy-first approach at a competitive entry price. If you manage multiple small blogs and want a consistent, super-clean interface, **Fathom Analytics** is highly appealing. If extreme simplicity and the most rigorous privacy standards are your absolute top priority, and you're fine with a more basic feature set, then **Simple Analytics** with its free hobby plan (or a paid plan for more history) is a strong contender."
}
],
"role": "model"
},
"finishReason": "STOP",
"index": 0,
"groundingMetadata": {
"searchEntryPoint": {
"renderedContent": "\n\n
\n
\n \n \n \n \n \n
\n \n \n \n \n \n \n
\n
\n
\n